This PP2 class has been one that has challenged me in so many ways, I learnt so much, not only about making an ad, but also about myself and the kind of person I am and what I like to do. That sounds cheesy, but unfortunately it is true. This semester challenged me to seriously think about my future and what I am capable of, and in the process I learnt what is actually involved in the production of an ad.
~~~~
When we started researching ads oh so long ago in Semester One, I don’t think I quite knew what I was getting myself in for. If you had told me that my idea would be one that people would want to make, and that I would be heading it up… I don’t think I would have believed you.
However, that is exactly what happened. To be honest, I’m still not entirely sure how that did actually happen. One minute I was telling my idea, not really thinking it was that great and that I’d instead be working on someone else’s idea, playing a more minor role (like I’m used to). Instead, Paul wrote up my name in BIG letters on the board, and then Meenal and Nary came on board, and then all of a sudden I was in the seat of power (as you might say).
~~~~
We got started right away with the animatic, but I think we got stuck on tiny details instead of really focusing on the important things like exactly what shots we wanted (I think we went quite rough instead of fine-tuning things). I think that was where I made a pretty big mistake as far as creative vision. I wasn’t communicating what was in my head properly, but I also was getting frustrated when what Meenal or Nary suggested wasn’t lining up to the picture I had in my head. Those two things don’t mix. That was probably one of my biggest learning curves, learning that it isn’t always possible to get the picture in your head exactly, and that there has to be give and take when it comes to actually knuckling down and making this thing.
I also think we wasted a lot of time on discussions about the final look of the piece, instead of actually working towards achieving that. Although ironically I also feel that we jumped too quickly into filming without doing our pre-production properly. So basically we wasted the time that we had.
I hate pre-production, but unfortunately it is a necessary evil. To some extent our pre-production process put me off the idea of producing ads for a living, because it was so hard to get the idea down onto paper. I understand how crucial the pre-production is, all the planning makes things so much easier later on, and the shoot becomes simple to edit together and you can spend more time on the fun stuff (like effects) instead of the basics. But I still hate it a lot.
Personally, I found that time period of pre-production to be quite frustrating, mostly because I’m not really all that used to having to stand up and defend my creative idea. I’m so used to working on projects with other people who have the strong idea and I just go with it. I think it’s a pretty big weakness of mine actually – I get so worried about becoming a bit of a dictator that I step back too much and let other people manipulate me and my ideas. But, you’ll be glad to know that I found my mean streak this time and stood up for myself and the product I was trying to create. I hate putting my foot down about things, but I know that letting quality slip is not good.
~~~~
We had to stand up for that standard of quality when we realised we had to re-shoot a scene. My goodness that was a horrible day! You see, the first time we shot it, we didn’t really know what we were doing. We tried to be organised, but when it came down to it there were so many more factors involved that I should have thought of. Like how the lighting would work, and the buttons themselves (we wasted so much time trying to stick the buttons to the wall). It just didn’t work. The lighting was all over the place, and even the 5D couldn’t make it look good enough. So with sinking hearts we decided to re-shoot in greenscreen, and make the thing much more abstract.
One good shoot we had though was down in the studio with proper lighting. Those shots are all pretty good, crisp and clear. So thankfully it was only one sequence that we had to re-shoot.
I went into shooting the greenscreen stuff with too much confidence, and not enough research. You see, the greenscreen experience I have has been a bit unpredictable. The best greenscreening that I have done has been using natural light and a big piece of green fabric, and the worst was the stuff we did for Button. I went in thinking that we could do it and it’d be easy! “It’s a greenscreen studio” I thought “it’ll have everything set up properly and we’ll be good!”. I was so wrong.
Week 11 I felt like shooting myself. In my limited knowledge of greenscreen, we had managed to shoot it with the wrong lighting, and the green was spilling onto the actress’s skin. By “actress” I mean me. That was frustrating. To say the least. We were thinking through how we would have to re-shoot it, again, and I was past it. I had been there since 9 that morning converting the footage to prores so that we could use it, and I was feeling pretty cooped up in the edit suites. So I went for a walk. A nice long walk down to Swanston Street and then back up around to Bowen and back to building 9. I felt like such an idiot. And to some extent I was an idiot. But I’m a firm believer that the world would not have progressed to this point without at least a few people who felt like idiots at one stage or other (Thomas Edison perhaps?), the big thing is that we have to move forward and learn from it instead of dwelling on the fact that we are idiots.
When I came back into the suites, the situation was much better.
Hoorah for the after effects guys! They suggested making it black and white, and when we did it, it actually looked pretty good. So we didn’t have to re-shoot.
As I’m writing this, we still aren’t finished with our ad. We still have a long way to go before it is good enough, but we are getting there. I’m determined not to let it get me down because it simply can’t. We don’t have time to waste on being glum and depressed that it isn’t working, we just have to get a move on and do it. Next up for us is sound. We have a few sound effects already, but we still have a fair bit of stuff to do with it. Then we need to finalise our edit, and colour correct (and finish up whatever greenscreen stuff there is).
~~~~
I spent a lot of time in the edit suites this semester. A LOT of time. There was always more footage to convert, or more things to render in, or stuff to bring across from my computer, and so yes. Out of the three of us, I was the one who spent the most time on the project. Strangely enough I didn’t mind spending a lot of time in the suites though, because I could always see the reasons behind it. I know that Prores is the best format to edit in, and so therefore our footage had to be in prores. There was no other way around it.
Actually, this is where I probably learnt the most as far as editing. I learnt a lot about what prores means, and whether prores lite is ok to use, and how to best convert footage. It was excellent. Instead of mucking around in Final Cut Pro to convert the files, I found out that you can do it with Compressor instead, and it works really well. Thanks Glenn! I was even able to turn around and help another group with it. That was a proud moment I think.
~~~~
As far as collaboration, I have this nagging doubt in the back of my mind that wonders whether I’m actually a team player. I always seem to have a lot more trouble with team projects than the other groups I see. But at the same time I have also seen how I have been able to work well in a group. I don’t really know what it is. I think this time around, I had my idea, and I had the devotion to it to be able to spend a lot of time on it, and so I found it hard to let other people in on ‘my’ project. It was a real struggle for me to delegate tasks, and to give my team members creative input as well. Goodness that makes me sound so pretentious, but it was how I felt. However, having now been through this, I think I am better equipped to be able to collaborate more nicely in the future.
~~~~
This semester has been a bit of an emotional rollercoaster really, one moment I’m feeling totally confident and happy with where things are going with our ad, the next my heart has sunk and I feel like such an idiot for making such stupid mistakes. But as Paul kept reminding me, it is good that I’m making these mistakes now, when I can learn from them without too many repercussions from the real world, instead of making the mistakes while I’m being paid to do my work. Now I know I’ll be extra careful about the planning, and I’ll do my research properly instead of just launching into things.
PP2, it was nice knowing you.

